Personal tools

Library submissions

From HaskellWiki

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(tweaks, collect extra refs at end)
Line 12: Line 12:
 
action by some committer. This slowed development.
 
action by some committer. This slowed development.
   
== Submitting a proposal ==
+
== Creating a proposal ==
   
 
In order to ensure we have something concrete to discuss, please follow
 
In order to ensure we have something concrete to discuss, please follow
the following guidelines when creating a new proposal:
+
the following guidelines:
   
* ''Submission''. Proposed changes should be submitted to libraries@haskell.org, as a [http://darcs.net darcs] patch.
 
 
* ''Patch''. The patch must compile against the head branch of the relevant library.
 
* ''Patch''. The patch must compile against the head branch of the relevant library.
 
* ''Style''. Follow the conventions in the library you are modifying.
 
* ''Style''. Follow the conventions in the library you are modifying.
Line 26: Line 25:
 
* ''Portability''. Code should be portable. If it is not portable, reasons should be given. Ensure the code runs in at least Hugs and GHC, Windows and Linux.
 
* ''Portability''. Code should be portable. If it is not portable, reasons should be given. Ensure the code runs in at least Hugs and GHC, Windows and Linux.
   
To document the change, please [http://hackage.haskell.org/trac/ghc/newticket?type=proposal&component=libraries/base add a Trac ticket] of type ''proposal'' for the appropriate library component, and a timescale for consideration (to focus the community's attention):
+
== Submitting the proposal ==
   
* ''Tracking''. The submission's trac ticket should be included in the mail sent to the libraries list. Here are the [http://hackage.haskell.org/trac/ghc/query?status=new&status=assigned&status=reopened&group=component&type=proposal&order=priority proposals currently under consideration].
+
* ''Tracking''. [http://hackage.haskell.org/trac/ghc/newticket?type=proposal&component=libraries/base Add a Trac ticket] of type ''proposal'' for the appropriate library component, with a timescale for consideration (to focus the community's attention).
  +
  +
* ''Submission''. Submit the proposed changes to libraries@haskell.org as a [http://darcs.net darcs] patch, referencing the trac ticket. (You can do this with ''darcs send''.)
  +
  +
Here are the [http://hackage.haskell.org/trac/ghc/query?status=new&status=assigned&status=reopened&group=component&type=proposal&order=priority proposals currently under consideration].
   
 
== At the end of the discussion period ==
 
== At the end of the discussion period ==

Revision as of 23:30, 25 October 2006

As the Haskell community has grown, and emphasis on development has moved from language to libraries, the need for a more formalised process for contributing to libraries has emerged. This page documents our 'best practices' for proposing changes to library interfaces (e.g. new modules or functions, removing functions), especially for modules in the base package.

In essence, we don't want proposals to go unnoticed, but changes to basic interfaces also need thorough consideration.

Under the old ad hoc system, unless a proposal meets with a chorus of approval, the only way to get a decision is from SimonM or unilateral action by some committer. This slowed development.

Contents

1 Creating a proposal

In order to ensure we have something concrete to discuss, please follow the following guidelines:

  • Patch. The patch must compile against the head branch of the relevant library.
  • Style. Follow the conventions in the library you are modifying.
  • Documentation. It must include valid Haddock documentation.
  • Tests. Code should also come with tests for the testsuite.
    • Pure code should also come with QuickCheck properties.
    • Impure code should have unit tests.
  • Portability. Code should be portable. If it is not portable, reasons should be given. Ensure the code runs in at least Hugs and GHC, Windows and Linux.

2 Submitting the proposal

  • Tracking. Add a Trac ticket of type proposal for the appropriate library component, with a timescale for consideration (to focus the community's attention).
  • Submission. Submit the proposed changes to libraries@haskell.org as a darcs patch, referencing the trac ticket. (You can do this with darcs send.)

Here are the proposals currently under consideration.

3 At the end of the discussion period

  • The proposer adds to the ticket a summary of the relevant parts of the discussion. (The summary is needed for anyone wondering about the change later: it's not reasonable to point people at a 50-message thread.)
  • If consensus was achieved, the change is made, with the commit message referring back to the ticket.
  • The ticket is closed (usually as fixed or wontfix).

A deeply held disagreement at this point may require some form of government (voting, dictatorship, etc). This should be a rare event.

Here are the archived past proposals.

4 See also